Showing posts with label U.S. History. Show all posts
Showing posts with label U.S. History. Show all posts

Friday, September 1, 2017

Traitors: Lee and Washington

I have seen quite a fee people on social media recently calling Robert E. Lee a traitor. While I agree with this accusation, I wonder if others follow their logic through.
If Lee is a traitor, then so is Washington. Lee betrayed his country (the US) and Washington betrayed his (Great Britain). Both men put aside their military uniforms of the country they had sworn an allegiance to defend and instead took up arms against their country, killing men that wore the uniform they once wore.
If anything, Washington is one-step further a traitor than Lee, if only because he formally aligned himself with France, a most shocking and backstabbing move, France being the enemy above all enemies to Great Britain at the time.
Perhaps the best thing to do is simply refrain from calling men like Lee and Washington traitors, especially since these men were, in all honesty, distinguished men of honor, and far greater men than any of us could hope to be in our lifetimes.

Monday, May 1, 2017

Cause of the American Civil War

“The American Civil War was over slavery!”  “No, it was over states’ rights!”  Back and forth the two sides go, on and on.  The American Civil war was actually over both issues.  To help explain how this can be, I will use an analogy I once heard used by Dr. R.C. Sproul in his explanation for the cause of the Protestant Reformation.  

“Frequently the Reformation is described as a movement that revolved around two pivotal issues.  The socalled ‘material’ cause was the debate over sola fide (“justification by faith alone”).  The ‘formal’ cause was the issue of sola Scriptura, that the Bible and the Bible alone has the authority to bind the conscience of the believer.”

The formal cause of the Civil War was over the issue of secession.  The United States (U.S.) did not invade the Confederate States (C.S) because the latter was pro-slavery.  The U.S. invaded the C.S. because the latter had seceded from the former’s union.  Some may interject here that the C.S. started the war when it attacked U.S. property, e.g. Fort Sumter, that fell within the new borders of the C.S.  This is a mute point as the mere act of secession already made claim to such property. (The picture to the right shows Fort Sumter flying a Confederate Flag in 1861.)

The material cause of the Civil War was over the issue of slavery.  The material cause of an issue is easier to discern when one asks the question, “Why was the formal cause an issue to begin with?”  In the Protestant Reformation, the formal issue (is a believer’s conscience bound by the Bible alone or by both the Bible and Church dogma) was only an issue because of the material cause (is a believer justified by their faith alone or by their faith and their works).  Those that believed one is justified by faith alone did so on the grounds that they believed one’s conscience is bound by the Bible alone.  In like manner, the formal cause of the Civil War (secession) was only an issue because of the material cause (slavery).

Take the American Revolutionary War (ARW) as another example.  The formal cause of the ARW was also the issue of secession.  Great Britain did not invade the British-American colonies because the latter refused to pay taxes, i.e. “no taxation without representation”. Great Britain invaded the British-American colonies because the latter rejected the former’s union.  This formal cause (secession), however, was only an issue because of the material cause (refusal to pay taxes), taxes which were levied, mind you, to pay a down the debt incurred when Great Britain defended the British-American colonists from French aggression during the Seven Years’ War.  In addition to these taxes, the colonists’ infamous smuggling practices were also finally put to a stop in order to drive goods away from the black market where it could be properly taxed.  Interesting how when a people’s money is put at risk, whether it be stopping slavery, smuggling, or tax evasion, those people have a tendency to rebel.  But perhaps that is a topic for another blog.

Wednesday, March 22, 2017

U.S. Atmospheric Nuclear Testing Research Continues


No, that is not a picture of the Sun to the right.  Rather it is what it would look like if a nuclear weapon detonated at night, 2 miles over your head.

History will always associate the U.S. with the discovery, testing, and war-time employment of nuclear weapons. The U.S. conducted 219 atmospheric nuclear tests alone between 1945 and 1962. If one includes exo-atmospheric, underground, and underwater, there were 1,054 tests. Since 1962, most of the films that captured the atmospheric tests (over 10,000, as multiple cameras were used during a test) have been slowly decomposing, scattered across the country in high-security vaults.

While a dark topic, it is never-the-less important for a nation to preserve it's history. Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) has therefore recently been authorized to collect and scan these films into digital form. This takes a great amount of time, but a few are already viewable on YouTube. 

While the preservation of these films is valuable for posterity's sake, new things are now being learned with 21st-century technology that wasn't possible 55 years ago. As such, these films continue to contribute data to current and future weapon physicists. 

Housatonic (pictured above) was one of many tests as part of Operation Dominic in 1962. Housatonic was a low-altitude test delivered via airdrop and detonated at 12,100 ft, (just over 2 miles above the surface).

This is a link to one of these new films.

Tuesday, July 1, 2014

Here's to Complicating Your 4th

Every 4th of July I have mixed feelings. There are, of course, the patriotic emotions that are hard to avoid when one is surrounded by loved ones under a firework filled night sky. Why the mixed feelings? As my wife often points out, I am a rule follower. I am most comfortable when I obey the established authority. As a child I obeyed my parents. As a Christian I obey God. As a citizen I obey my government. In this context I realize that I would most likely have been a Loyalist during the time of the American Revolution. I cannot see myself taking up arms against my country, in that case England, and my King. 

I sympathize greatly with the often misunderstood "traitor," Benedict Arnold. He first fought beside his countrymen (English & American colonists) in 1755 against the tyranny of France and their terrorizing Indian tactics during the French and Indian War. Later, believing in the American struggle against British oppression, Arnold took up arms against his country and became the most brilliant soldier of the Continental Army, most notably at the Battle of Saratoga, at which his right leg was desperately wounded. His private correspondence displayed both a spirit of rebellion against tyranny and a desire to see America eventually rekindle her communion with England.  However, Arnold was beside himself upon learning of the Franco/American alliance of 1778, an unthinkable treason to any British-American. Arnold changed sides and once again fought for his King.  Having traded his blue coat for a red one, Arnold later asked a captured Continental officer what the Americans would do if they captured him.  The officer replied, “Cut off your right leg, bury it with full military honors, and then hang the rest of you on a gibbet.”

I do not live during the American Revolutionary era, however. The American colonists won and I live on this side of history. I have since attempted to take up and participate in this experiment of liberty and the spirit of rebellion against tyranny. The mixed feelings continue, however, and will likely endure for some time.

Tuesday, September 17, 2013

A Few Thoughts this Constitution Day

The U.S. Constitution is not a perfect document.  When ratified in 1789, the Constitution provided an opportunity for slavery to continue, despite the practice’s inherent contradictory nature with the rights of man.  Some jaws may drop here; the Constitution was meant to be changeable.  Before you grab the tar and feathers, hear me out.  The rule of law is also important and if the Constitution is to be changed, we need to do so in the way the document was designed to be changed.  An example was when the Constitution was amended to outlaw alcohol, also known as The Prohibition.  The fact that Prohibition killed people through the production of lethal alcohol and gave power to the criminals is, while true, beside the point.  While conducted with poor judgment, at least the U.S. Legislature of 1918 had enough understanding and respect for the Constitution to actually use it.  

Today, many laws are passed without giving a second thought to the necessity of enforcing such measures via the Constitution.  While Major Bloomberg attempted to regulate the consumption of soda in New York City, as ridiculous as that was, at least it was at a local level where it belongs.  At the federal level, there are many agencies that write rules and regulations, the most infamous being the IRS.  The Constitution prohibits any entity except for the U.S. Legislature to write laws that demand compliance from its citizens.  The genius of the drafters of the Constitution was in understanding the necessity of checks and balances, in giving each branch certain roles and responsibilities.  The Legislative branch writes laws and declares war.  Let them do it.

Saturday, June 23, 2012

War of 1812: An Example of the Value in a Congressional Declaration of War


A few years back, I got into a disagreement with a Canadian friend over who won the War of 1812; America or Canada/Britain?  I had been taught through the American public school system that we had won.  My friend had been taught in his native land that Canada had won.  Who was right?  Turns out, we both were. 

Two hundred years ago, and as recently as World War II, wars were declared in accordance with the U.S. Constitution, specifically, through a formal declaration from Congress.  This was done for several important reasons.  The first was that an approval from Congress signified that a war had the nation’s approval, namely the people and states they represented.  Second, wars are to be formally declared by Congress so that clear objectives could be established.  Once those objectives were met, the war would end.  Let me repeat that.  Once objectives set by Congress were met, the war would end. 

There were several but two main objectives the United States sought to accomplish by starting war with the British Empire in 1812.  The first was to stop the British Royal Navy from pressing American seamen into their service.  Basically, the British were kidnapping our citizens.  Second, the United States wanted to put a stop to the British and Canadian practice of inciting Native American attacks against American pioneers on our nation’s western borders.  Today, we would likely call this “terrorism,” but the British and French use of Native Americans in this manner was a common practice by 1812.
 
The Canadians had their own objective, too, as my friend pointed out; prevent the Americans from taking over their country!  By 1814 the British had stopped kidnapping U.S. sailors and coaxing Native American attacks against Americans.  The Canadians had also successfully prevented the United States from taking over Canada.  With objectives met by both belligerents, the war ended.  The war lasted only two years!  Imagine that, if you can.

The U.S. started the War of 1812 two hundred years ago this month.  At least President Madison went to war legally through a declaration of war from Congress, a forgotten practice for our now Constitutionally ignorant and indifferent nation.